Stage 3 of 8
START HEREDesigning the review formEverything else in this stage hangs off the review form, so build it first.Reviewing
Reviewing is where your reviewers score submissions before you make decisions. You'll design a review form, recruit and assign reviewers, open reviewing, then keep an eye on progress — stepping in where a review needs chasing or finishing.
Setting up
Before your reviewers see anything.
- Review question typesAs well as the default questions, you can add supplementary questions, should you require. They are split into various types.
- Tips on designing your reviewing formThe review form templates are designed to be very flexible but in order to collect the information you need and to make…
- Creating the reviewer recruitment form and assign categoriesLearn how to create your reviewer form, either manually or bulk upload reviewers, how to use the reviewer table and assign categories to reviewers.
- Controlling what the reviewer can seeYou can determine which questions' responses will be visible to the reviewer, along with the submitters' individual information (eg. name and email address).
While reviewing is open
Assigning work and keeping it moving.
- Assigning and unassigning a submission to a reviewerLearn how to automatically assign, manually assign and un-assign submissions to reviewers.
- Opening and closing reviewingIn order to make the review system live, you will need to open reviews.
- Notifying reviewers that they have been assigned submissions to reviewAfter adding reviewers and assigning submissions to them, you will need to notify them via the notifying reviewers email template.
- The review tablesThe review tables are very useful tools for having an overview of review information, and to manipulate and extract data.
Fixing problems
The things that go wrong, and what to do about them.
- Chasing up late reviewsYou may want to chase up reviewers if their reviews are incomplete and the deadline is approaching.
- Editing a review or completing a review on behalf of a reviewerYou can edit or complete a review on behalf of an assigned reviewer, should you require.
- Showing reviews to submittersBy default, reviews are not made available to submitters (just their acceptance status). If you would like submitters to view their reviews, follow the guidance below. It is not available in the FREE package.
Also in this section
- Designing the review formExplore the settings and tools that will help you design the review form for your requirements.
- If your reviewers can't see their assigned submissionsA reviewer signs in and finds nothing waiting, or is told they have not been assigned anything. Work down this list — the first two causes account for most of it.